21st Century Idiot
Tue ,23/06/2009I promised tQ a proper Tuesday post, and for the most part I am a man of my word! What transpires below, is something that I have been thinking about for awhile now and finally just wanted to get off my chest.
In 2004 when American Idiot was released, it was a calling out to the country. A declaration that the country was in a bad spot, and it took a gang of punks in order to let this generation know about it. The themes were obvious; the war in Iraq, a President and leadership specializing in fear mongering, and the youth of the country falling into waste and ruin. No one can question how good the album was, nor will I spend any part of blog trying to tell you how I feel about it. You all know that I feel like American Idiot is one of the best albums ever made. The question now becomes … was it really necessary to make ANOTHER rock opera immediately after such a perfect album?
Green Day has just released 21st Century Breakdown their follow up to Idiot and a completely new rock opera narrative. You won’t find old Whatshername coming back to make a cameo, nor will St. Jimmy be magically brought back from the dead. No Jimmy is still dead with a gunshot to his head, but what we have in Breakdown are the characters of Gloria and Christian. Whereas Idiot was content on talking about the problems of raising a family in the era of the “W” and Iraq, watching as communities are torn apart by children not coming home (whether it be the army or via drugs), Breakdown takes a more active approach at spitting venom at modern technology, prescription drugs, and organized religion to name a few.
The subject matter has changed a bit, but the style in which Green Day tells the tale is pretty much the same. This is where my first issue with the album comes in. It’s not exact, but it’s damn close enough. The opening song is essentially filler, but it is followed by the title track, a 6 minute song that changes styles as you go on, describing the world that we live in. Sound familiar? It should, it’s what they did with “Jesus of Suburbia” on Idiot. The rest of the album is filled with songs that don’t sound the same, but fit the same build as songs on American Idiot. They even seem to come in the same order, so therefore you are stuck making direct comparisons to the albums.
Idiot talked about hard drug use, whereas Breakdown talks about abuse of prescription drugs and over diagnosing. Idiot attacked the government, and Breakdown attacks the catholic church. The back and forth with the similarities continue throughout and while it’s not a terrible thing, it feels very cookie cutter. It might just be that I have listened to Idiot too much, but I don’t think I’m alone in that. I’m sure others have noticed that at similar points in both albums, as you are listening you might be expecting them to go in a different direction, but they take the safe route instead and give you something similar to what you heard in 2004.
Musically Green Day have really hit their stride though. They sound good, and are incorporating their full arsenal of additional performers. Violin’s, acoustic guitars, timpanis and much more can all be heard in full effect. That’s the good thing, but unfortunately Billie Joe Armstrong decides that the album should have a song dedicated to one topic per additional instrument he uses seemingly. If the album was just shots against the things that I have mentioned above it would be similar to Idiot but at least it would be focused. Not so on Breakdown. The album hits religion, politics, the war, drugs, detorating conditions in major cities, and the nasty influence of mordern media and technology. That’s a lot of songs to get through, and it would be fine if it was just a normal album. Green Day though wanted Breakdown to be a rock opera and as a narrative, there’s just too much stuff that they are talking about at once. The storyline starts to breakdown (haha, get it?), and as a result you either forget about Gloria and Christian or simply don’t care by the end.
Finally, the last problem that I personally had with the album is the timing of the album’s release. This is a two pronged complaint. From an easy spot, I mean it’s the next album after Idiot. Breakdown brought upon a direct comparison and unfortunately it’s almost impossible to make a better rock opera back to back. I don’t care how talented you are it’s tough to keep that momentum up. Not even The Who did that, instead elected to follow up Tommy with Who’s Next, one of the band’s biggest commercial successes.
The last part of the problem is the timing with where the country is right now. In 2004 the country, specifically young democrats such as myself were still in college and needed an anthem to rally behind to show their displeasure with not only George Bush being re-elected, and not only with the Democratic party giving us no good candidates, but also with our friends fighting in Iraq. American Idiot was that album, as it stood for everything that we wanted to say to those in charge. All I remember is playing the album in my dorm room with Katie, Pedro and Sundeep with me. What started as harmless background music while we talked, turned into an epic listening party as no one said anything after the second track in an effort to absorb all that was coming out of the surround sound. All we could say at the end was … “wow”.
With 21st Century Breakdown the problem lies in that right now Green Day want to spit some more venom at the world, but the things they are yelling at I don’t necessarily feel like we have to be campaigning for so much. Sure the economy is in the tanks, but we have a new President in office and love him and hate him it’s a time of change and hope. Now we don’t need to be hearing about every single one of our problems with no suggestions for what can be done. Instead now we know the issues, and we want to tighten our belts and get to work. Unfortunately for Green Day they want to start a revolution, and the revolution was already started. It ends up sounding like they are late to the party.
Does this mean that 21 Century Breakdown is a bad album? Not in the least, it’s a very good album. Green Day just shot themselves in the foot by making such an iconic album before hand. It’s a tough legacy to live up to, and one that they don’t ultimately make. I can listen to selected tracks off of Breakdown but if Green Day was hoping that I would get goosebumps after every song like I did with American Idiot … well I’m sorry to disappoint guys.



For the past few years, LOST has been a staple show in my viewing rotation. Many times, it has been the only thing that I felt was worth watching. Now for some people, their intrigue for LOST is something that just spawned after watching the first season and seeing all the weird things happen and how people tried to deal with it. Some might have even been enticed by the flashbacks and the connections that people had to other characters. All fine reasons to like the show, but I know for me my obsession for the show was tied to one very specific moment.